Travel Packing Tips: How We Went From Overpacked Suitcases to Backpacks
Updated: Oct 14
The evolution of our packing habits, a few lessons learned the hard way, and why we're probably not finished changing our minds.
It Started With Half of Jenn's Closet
Every country we visit requires a slightly different packing strategy. Actually, even within the United States, what we bring depends on where we're going, how we're getting there, and what we plan to do.
We've learned there really isn't one right way to pack. What works perfectly for one trip might be completely wrong for the next. These aren't travel packing tips we learned from a guidebook. They're lessons we've picked up through trial, error, and a few overstuffed suitcases.
And trust us, we've tried a few different ways.
When we first started road-tripping, packing wasn't much of a concern. We had a car, after all. There was room for a suitcase, a backpack, or sometimes two suitcases, depending on how many outfits Jenn thought she might need.
Chris has always been a dress-for-dinner kind of guy. We enjoy finding a nice restaurant when we travel, which meant Jenn needed something appropriate to wear.
And apparently, several backup options.
Jenn isn't particularly girly, but back then she packed a makeup bag full of things she might need to get ready for dinner. Between the clothes, shoes, and everything else, it sometimes felt like half her wardrobe was coming along.
As long as we were driving, who cared?
Then we started flying more.
St. Croix Changed Everything

Our trip to St. Croix involved one very large, very overfilled suitcase.
After hauling that thing around and dealing with the customs process, we decided there had to be a better way.
Before our next adventure, we started researching carry-on luggage.
That sounds simple enough until you realize every airline seems to have its own opinion about what qualifies as a carry-on.
We spent hours comparing sizes, brands, and features. Eventually, we each bought a rolling carry-on suitcase. Different brands, but both had telescoping handles, wheels, and locks on the zippers. We chose sizes that would work with most of the airlines we expected to use.
We also each carried a backpack as our personal item. Jenn simply stuffed her purse inside hers.
Suddenly, traveling felt easier.
We figured out how to fit seven days' worth of clothes into our carry-ons. We even started using one small suitcase and a backpack for shorter trips.
Ten days in Costa Rica with our new lighter packing system?
A dream.
We thought we'd finally figured it out.
Of course, traveling has a way of proving you wrong.
Honduras: A Different Trip, A Different Plan
For our ten-day adventure in Honduras, we had a rental car, so we decided to try something different.
This time, we checked one large suitcase and brought our two smaller suitcases and backpacks.
Most of our clothes and snorkeling gear went into the big bag. Once we had the rental car, we could leave the large suitcase in the trunk when appropriate and take only what we needed into our accommodations.
It actually worked really well.
But we were starting to notice something about those convenient little rolling suitcases.
They're fantastic in airports.
Old sidewalks? Not so much.
Stairs? Definitely not.
And there's nothing quite like trying to drag a suitcase over uneven pavement while it repeatedly attacks your ankles.
We loved traveling lighter, but we were beginning to wonder whether wheels were really the answer.
Then Peru came along.
Peru: Two Weeks, Multiple Flights, Trains, and One Big Packing Question
Peru was going to be our biggest adventure yet.
Two weeks of traveling, different destinations, airplanes, trains, plenty of moving around, and no rental car.
Which raised one very important question:
How in the world were we going to pack for this?
Naturally, Jenn hit Google.
She was researching what to wear, what the weather might be like, and how much luggage the different airlines and trains would allow.
Chris was researching something else entirely.
How to carry all of it.
That's when he discovered the Osprey Farpoint 55 and a Cotopaxi backpack.
Jenn was skeptical.
Very skeptical.
Chris found both bags on eBay, and when they arrived, we started comparing them.
Neither of us was particularly impressed with the Cotopaxi. It was basically one large space without the organization we wanted.
But the older-style Osprey Farpoint 55?
Now that was interesting.
The Backpack That Won Us Over
The Farpoint 55 had a feature we really liked: a detachable daypack that zipped onto the larger pack.
The daypack had two sections and a front zippered pocket, which made organizing the smaller things much easier.
With a little creativity, we even found places to attach water bottles.
The main pack also had a lightweight frame, and the shoulder straps could be zipped away. If we needed to check the bag, it became more like a duffel, without straps hanging loose and getting caught in airport baggage equipment.

And we discovered one more unexpected feature.
When it's zipped up like a duffel bag, the Farpoint makes a surprisingly decent pillow.
Not that we went looking for that feature.
But when you find yourself stuck sleeping on an airport floor, you learn to appreciate a backpack that doubles as a pillow.
Is it comfortable?
Well, it's better than the floor.
Chris ordered another Farpoint.
Except the new version wasn't the same.
So back to eBay he went, determined to find another older-style Farpoint 55 like the first.
Eventually, he found one.
Now we each had a backpack.
Chris had also read that a lot of travelers' bags look alike, so we sewed patches onto ours to make them easy to recognize.

That turned out to be a great decision, especially when we stored our bags at a train station.
We also put Apple AirTags in our luggage.
If there's one small thing we'd recommend considering, it's a luggage tracker. Whether your bag is checked, stored, or traveling with you, knowing where it is can offer a little extra peace of mind.
Did the Backpacks Work in Peru?
They worked better than we expected.
Flying to and from the United States on American Airlines, our packs were accepted as carry-ons.
Within Peru, it was a different story.
Sometimes we could carry the main packs onto the plane. Other times, we had to check them at the gate.
On our flights, we noticed that our seating and boarding arrangements seemed to make a difference. When we had paid for premium seating, we were able to keep the larger packs with us. Without it, we sometimes had to gate-check them.
That's just what happened on our trip, though. Airline baggage rules vary, and we'd always recommend checking the current requirements before flying.
But the real test wasn't the airplanes.
It was everything in between.
Instead of dragging suitcases across old sidewalks, up stairs, and through crowded places, we could zip the daypacks onto the main bags, throw everything on our backs, and go.
No more fighting with suitcase wheels.
No more banging a rolling suitcase into our shins.
And no more trying to figure out how to carry a suitcase up a staircase while holding onto everything else.
For two weeks of moving around Peru, it made an enormous difference.
We were hooked.

Yes, We Even Use Packing Cubes Now
We weren't completely sold on packing cubes at first.
Jenn watched videos, read reviews, and eventually bought some inexpensive ones from Amazon so we could try them without spending a fortune.
Turns out, we like them.
They help keep our clothes organized and make it easier to find what we're looking for without unpacking the entire bag.
We also started doing something before big trips that has been surprisingly helpful.
We pack everything ahead of time.
Not the night before we leave. We actually do a trial run to make sure everything fits.
It's a great way to figure out what you're missing, what takes up too much room, and what you probably don't need in the first place.
And if Jenn can convince herself she doesn't need that extra outfit, that's a bonus.
One Great Idea That Didn't Quite Work
Chris came up with another idea for Peru.
He wanted a small Velcro pouch that could attach to our backpack straps and hold our passports.
That way, we wouldn't have to dig through bags or pockets every time we needed them.
The idea was excellent.
The pouch we bought?
Not so much.
It didn't hold up the way we'd hoped, so we're still looking for a better solution.
We haven't given up on the idea. We just need to find something secure and durable enough to trust with important documents.
Another lesson learned.
Our Travel Packing Tips: Have We Finally Figured It Out?
Maybe.
At least until the next trip.
Chris has always been the lighter packer of the two of us, and he's pretty happy with his setup.
Jenn has come a long way from bringing half her closet and a makeup bag full of things she rarely used.
These days, she doesn't even pack a makeup bag.
Not because she's mastered some complicated minimalist beauty routine.
It's just not who she is.
We've also cut back on the number of dressy outfits we bring. We still enjoy a nice dinner, but we've gotten better at choosing clothes that can work for more than one occasion.
And with a little help from shipping stores and a few trial runs, Jenn has figured out how to make her backpack work for her, too.
We never thought we'd be the people traveling for two weeks with backpacks.
But here we are.
The Next Packing Challenge: Back to St. Croix
We're planning another trip to St. Croix, this time for four days of snorkeling.
And once again, we're asking ourselves the same question:
How are we going to pack all of this?
We're hoping to fit everything we need, including our snorkeling gear, into our Osprey backpacks.
Will it work?
We'll find out.
Check back after the first of the year to see whether we managed to pull it off or whether our brilliant packing system needs another adjustment.
Because if there's one thing traveling has taught us, it's that you never really stop learning.
And sometimes the best travel advice comes from doing something the hard way first.
Comments